A University Afraid of Philosophy Is a World Afraid of Thought
📅•⏱️3 min read

A University Afraid of Philosophy Is a World Afraid of Thought

Texas A&M has reportedly told a philosophy professor to stop teaching Platoon the grounds that it allegedly promotes contemporary “gender or race ideology.” When Plato is suddenly too controversial for a philosophy class, it is hard not to worry, because if this is where the line is drawn, the next step is probably asking whether Aristotle makes people elitist or whether Homer is unsafe because he wrote about anger and grief.

The real issue, of course, is not Plato or race and gender ideology, but the simple fact that thinking makes people inconvenient. Asking questions has always been a problem for those who prefer obedient minds, and history is full of moments where the solution to that problem was to limit what people were allowed to read or discuss. Calling ideas dangerous has always been an easier move than actually arguing with them.

Plato, of course, knew this well, because his teacher Socrates was executed for doing nothing more radical than asking people to explain themselves. He was accused of corrupting the youth, and introducing new ideas that challenged traditional beliefs. His crime was not political rebellion in the narrow sense, but persistent questioning, encouraging young people to think beyond what they are told.

Even then, the warning was clear: curiosity is tolerated right up to the moment it becomes inconvenient. Ironically, The Symposium belongs to the very intellectual tradition born from that act of repression, which should tell us something about how badly censorship tends to backfire.

Subscribe now


The same story appeared in medieval Europe, where the Catholic Church maintained the Index Librorum Prohibitorum, a list of banned books deemed heretical or morally dangerous. Works by Aristotle were at times restricted or heavily redacted because their ideas could encourage independent reasoning outside church doctrine. Control over education was a means of controlling belief.

In the twentieth century, political regimes repeatedly used censorship in education to consolidate power. Nazi Germany purged “un-German” texts from universities and libraries, targeting Jewish authors and modern thinkers whose ideas challenged racial ideology. In the Soviet Union, philosophy and science were filtered through Marxist-Leninist orthodoxy and books that deviated from official ideology were banned. In both cases, the goal was to silence knowledge and enforce ideological conformity.

Even in democratic societies, ideological fear have driven educational censorship. During the McCarthy era in the United States, teachers and professors were fired or blacklisted for suspected ideological sympathies. Literature and philosophy were scrutinised for subversive content, and academic freedom suffered under the belief that exposure to certain ideas could threaten national loyalty.

So when a modern university treats Plato as a threat, it is not a shocking development so much as a very old habit resurfacing in new language. The tragedy is not that students might encounter challenging ideas, but that they might not. Removing books like the Symposium does not shield young people from harm, it just narrows the world they are allowed to see.

Meanwhile, while the U.S. is busy banning books, on the other side of the world, others are busy building libraries.

Thanks for reading Chronicles of a Liquid Society! This post is public so feel free to share it.

Share


📬

Newsletter

Stay updated with new articles.

0 Comments

Sign in to join the conversation.

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

© 2026 Modern Times , Powered by Writizzy