
Be The Tree That Bends
A few days ago, someone whose opinion I value, suggested that I read an essay with the intriguing title āWhy Is Everyone In Tech So Sad?ā by Aaron Horwath, introduced with an odd image of someone knitting. I ād like to begin by saying that I am a devoted knitter, so I found the image far more intriguing than the title. For me, knitting is one of the most wonderful and comforting things in the world.
With that clarified, let us move to the actual subject: the essay. Its argument is that knowledge workers are experiencing a deep, existential crisis , āintensified by AIās rapid integration into the workplace. AI is exposing how abstract and often pointless knowledge work really is, and with it, the identity, meaning and sense of belonging we have built around our jobs.
Mostly, I agree with the thesis, but I donāt think AI caused or even necessarily intensified the crisis. I think AI simply exposed something that was already there, and weāve been avoiding looking too closely because we were afraid of what we will discover. To use the everyday expression: the elephant in the room.
The essay uses a term I hadnāt met before: Workism . It basically describes the modern habit of asking a job to provide what earlier generations asked of religion: meaning, belonging, identity.
There is of course, a problem with this arrangement which Aaron Horwath acknowledges. Workism only works if you donāt look at it too closely, because ālike religion, it relies on faithās triumph over logic.ā
I want to believe that I, mostly, look at things logically (I blame my over-exposure to Star Trek world and especially Spock for this conviction). Growing up in Greece, a country where religion still has a considerable presence in everyday life, I always assumed people got up for work chasing money and for the more complicated satisfaction of proving something to themselves and to other people. Certainly not communion. But thatās just my personal interpretation, which if you look closely enough, itās another kind of faith.
And then comes AI. Suddenly you discover that the ladder of promotion and security is disappearing. The old promise that hard work, experience, knowledge, and higher earnings would lead to security no longer applies. What do you do? What happens when the ladder disappears? For the record: mine has disappeared underneath my feet more than once. Yet here I am.
So perhaps the question is not really what replaces the ladder. Perhaps the question is why we thought we needed one in the first place.
Embrace uncertainty.
We are taught that uncertainty is not a good thing. I disagree. Uncertainty is good and when you learn to live with it, life becomes easier, less stressful and you are better prepared for the future.
It may sound paradoxical, but it is not. And I will explain why.
Most of what we care about, outcome of decisions, other peopleās intentions that affect us, the future in general, is unpredictable. Pretending you know what exactly will happen tomorrow, does not make things more certain. It just proves that we donāt understand reality.
If you accept that the future is unpredictable, you make better decisions. Thatās because you allow flexibility into your life. Being flexible does not mean being unstable, it means being more resilient. Nassim Nicholas Taleb has written an excellent book on resilience that I highly recommend. But since life has become more complicated, and most people prefer a oneāminute video that explains almost nothing, Iāll use an example instead.
Picture two trees in a storm. One is stiff, one bends. You already know which one survives, the one that bends. Bending isnāt weakness, itās how a tree stays standing. People who built their identity on a fixed job description are the stiff tree. AI is the storm. And it turns out the tree that never doubted itself was never as safe as it thought it would be. Confidence does not equal actual safety, my friends.
This is where the discussion becomes more interesting than the usual debate about whether AI will take our jobs. We thought we were building careers, but we were also building identities around things that were never entirely under our control.
Research shows that most people do seek purpose and look for identity . Viktor Franklās work (Book: Manās Search for Meaning ) argues that meaning-seeking is a primary human drive, even under extreme suffering. But I would argue that this is a contested claim, not a settled fact. The focus on individual āpurposeā and self-actualised āidentityā is a modern, Western preoccupation. There are cultures that organise life around duty, family, or survival without needing a personal āpurpose narrative.ā Buddhism, for example, argues that the craving for a fixed self/identity is itself a source of suffering, and that people can function well without it.
So perhaps we donāt need a stronger identity but a looser one. Loose identity is a term introduced by the philosopher Donald L.M. Baxterand it shows how identity can be pragmatic rather than strict, something that shifts over time. I like the concept because it removes some of the drama weāve seen unfold in this part of the world over the last few years, and because ā on a personal level- it reflects who I am.
Because I am, and at the same time I am not, the same person I was twenty years ago. Mostly, I see myself as a working draft, not a finished document . Open to revisions whenever life delivers unexpected things or new experiences. Sometimes you add new paragraphs, or you discover that that section you thought was one of the most important, itās actually rather boring. So you remove it completely.
Purpose can work the same way. Itās always looseāsomething that can take many forms, rather than something that lives or dies with a single job, title, or company. It can be found in learning something new, raising a family, building something, making something beautiful, or simply becoming interested in something you had previously ignored. Life is a journey, sometimes pleasant, sometimes rough, but not a fixed destination.
So, this is the message (If you want to take it): Be the tree that bends.
Life isnāt just a job description. Your title is not your identity. Sometimes purpose, joy, and knowledge appear in jobs or places you never expected to find. So go ahead, try and learn new things. Change your mind.
And maybe do something with your hands that has absolutely nothing to do with your job title. I recommend knitting, but Iām biased.
As for me, I am going to read Guy DebordāsāThe Society of the Spectacle. According to the writer of the essay it is āsimultaneously exciting and impenetrable.ā Exactly the kind of book I love to read. And of course, I will knit.
Thank you for reading this Old Trouble. If you liked this piece or found it useful, share it, or consider subscribing. Or buy me a virtual coffee as caffeine keeps this whole enterprise running.
āļø Written by
Newsletter
Stay updated with new articles.

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!