Marcus Aurelius, Epictetus, Spock, and the Strange Afterlife of Stoicism
đŸ“…â€ąâ±ïž9 min read

Marcus Aurelius, Epictetus, Spock, and the Strange Afterlife of Stoicism

Over the last decade or so, Stoicism seems to be everywhere. Ryan Holiday and Stephen Hanselman’s book The Daily Stoichas been a bestseller, while Marcus Aurelius’ Meditations is apparently in every bookshelf. As a Greek with a classical education, imperfect though it was, I totally understand why people are so attracted to ideas from Greek and Roman antiquity when trying to deal with the crazy stress of modern life.

When you look at modern places like the U.S., they’re not all that different from the ancient societies where Stoicism flourished. A lot of the same pressures are still around: massive inequality, a slide toward political authoritarian politics, and a growing sense of political powerlessness, even among the rich. When the world around you feels this chaotic, it’s easy to slip into feeling helpless. No wonder Stoicism feels right at home.

Stoicism philosophy has become a mental comfort system, for the wealthy and the well-off for the unfortunate moments when the universe refuses to obey them. If you cannot control what happens outside yourself, the Stoic answer is simple. No need to worry, concentrate on what remains within your control, and remember that you are still in charge of what is really important. It’s an attractive and a powerful idea, and it is also where the trouble begins.

Stoicism was founded in Athens by Zeno in the 4^th^ century BCE as a version of the philosophy of Socrates and was comprised of three parts: physics (phusikĂȘ ), logic (logikĂȘ), and ethics (ĂȘthikĂȘ), basically, a set of teachings about the mindset and the habits you need to attain wisdom and well-being, that is, eudaimonia, a Greek word that most of the time is wrongly translated as happiness.

For a Stoic, as for an Epicurean, well-being is not about feeling cheerful but about control. They both sought ataraxia, that is, peace of mind, a state of inner calm, untroubled from fear or anxiety. Where they disagreed about was what you can control.

Stoics thought you can control your inner world, your reactions, your judgments, and how you interpret what happens to you. Everything else—health, wealth, or how other people behave—is outside your control, so focus on what’s inside.

Epicureans view human psychology more realistically. They argued that you cannot simply decide to not feel hurt when someone betrays you. You can’t think your way out of grief or anxiety, what you can do instead is to focus on managing your life choices.

So, Stoics believe in willpower. Epicureans believe in wisdom, and despite how the word is used today, Epicureanism is not about seeking pleasure.

Subscribe now


A modern “stoic” is often understood as someone who endures pain or hardship without complaining and without showing emotion, but ancient Stoics didn’t repress feelings, they retrained them through reason and practice. In their view, having good character (virtue) is the only thing that matters. Everything else - pain, grief, frustration - is technically “indifferent.” Once you realize external stuff can’t touch who you really are, it loses its power to ruin your day.

In modern terms, think about losing your job, watching your savings crash because of the AI bubble, or dealing with a serious medical problem. To a Stoic, these are all tough events, but they are external, they don’t define who you really are or ruin your ability to live a good life. The goal is to refuse to let life’s challenges hijack your brain and destroy your ability to act wisely. Whatever happens, you stay cool, calm, and grounded even when everything around you is falling apart.

The desire for peace of mind was common among people of all social classes, not only the rich and powerful. One of the most important ancient teachers of Stoicism was Epictetus, who was born as a slave but succeeded in getting an education and eventually his freedom.

Having been born into slavery, he understood better than anyone that while you can’t always control your physical circumstances or status, your mind and moral choices are always your own. Epictetus taught in Rome in the 2^nd^ century C.E and the central theme of his teaching was that we can and must choose to stop paying attention to the things we have no control over. “Wealth, health status, these things aren’t up to us,” he said. Everyone who has read about the Romans, they would know that in Roman culture, especially among Stoics, it was considered undignified to be concerned with money or prestige; true dignity came from virtue and self‑mastery rather than external possessions or honours. Of course, the reality was much more complicated.

Epictetus’s version of Stoicism posed no threat to existing social norms. Diogenes the Cynichas shown his contempt for convention by living in a barrel, wearing rugs and defecating in public. But Epictetus recommended that we should adapt ourselves with dignity to perform whatever social role we find ourselves inhabiting (kathēkon). This is not a philosophy to inspire a slave revolt, or a revolution, or, in today’s terms, a political or social change.

Share


The most famous and most powerful of all Stoics was, of course, the emperor Marcus Aurelius, who wrote Meditations as a private journal to remind himself how to stay grounded and live wisely. Today, it remains a favourite handbook for many world leaders and business executives. Marcus ruled through economic crises, rising inequality, endless wars and devastating plagues, mindless entertainment, and religious fanaticism. If that sounds familiar, you are not wrong.

Marcus Aurelius was a Roman patriot, no doubt about that. Although he described himself as “a citizen of the universe,” Rome was more than one place to him, it was an idea deeply intertwined to his sense of honour and duty. “Every hour, give rigorous attention, as Roman, and as a man, to the performance of the task at hand.” For him, and many Stoic-minded Romans, being stoic and being Roman, that means having the strong, masculine virtue (virtus literally means masculinity) was the same thing.

How should we view the surging popularity of Stoicism and “neo-Stoicism” across the Western world? today? Like monotheistic religions, it offers the comforting promise of being able to find peace and live a good life amid the chaos and uncertainty of recent times. But it also promotes three specific ideals - rationality, power, and masculinity. Unlike religions that urge followers to surrender the ego, Stoicism keeps the self at the center. A Stoic never truly gives up his desire for power, possessions, or ambitions that can be achieved through control of the will. This helps explain why it is so popular among the wealthy, mostly white men who want to hold onto their status and control.

Nevertheless, Stoicism provides a great deal of practical guidance for daily life. When a train or flight gets delayed, reminding yourself that it’s beyond your control helps you stay calm and think logically. It’s not always easy to accept life’s annoyances without complaining -I’m still a work in progress - but it really helps.

It can also help with physical pain or disturbed sleep. During a recent bout of insomnia, instead of getting angry or miserable, I chose to take control. I carried on as usual and used those sleepless hours to read, cook, or work, basically, I took control of my thoughts and body.

Subscribe now


Perhaps the ultimate Stoic in modern pop culture is Spock of Star Trek. Those who have immersed themselves in the Star Trek universe, me included, would recognise the traits of his character: disciplined, rational, self‑controlled, and committed to virtue. Gene Roddenberry intentionally created Spock as a Stoic figure and brilliantly used the dynamic between Spock, Kirk, and McCoy to dramatize philosophical tensions, with McCoy representing passion, emotion, and humanist morality, Spock representing Stoic rationality, emotional discipline, and detachment, and, of course, Kirk, a synthesis of the two, representing strong will and practical wisdom.

Spock captures both sides of the philosophy. On the surface, his emotional detachment looks like the popular misconception of Stoicism as cold emotional suppression. Yet his deep commitment to duty, justice, and self-sacrifice reflects authentic Stoic virtue. Ultimately, Spock embodies both the stereotype and the true ideal of Stoicism.

Of course, in real life things are a bit different. Epictetus discusses a man who leaves home when his child is sick because he cannot bear to contemplate her suffering of the possibility of her death. He recognises that this is not the most ‘affectionate’ thing to do, just imagine if the mother of the child had done the same, the child would be left completely alone and probably in danger. Epictetus does not explain why she has chosen to stay, probably because she was more concerned with the child’s need than her own feelings.

This event, while extreme, raises a few uncomfortable questions. What happens when emotional detachment stops being self-discipline and becomes an excuse for refusing responsibility? What if the people who have the greatest power are also the people who have trained themselves most successfully not to care?

Viewed this way, Stoicism starts to resemble a refined kind of egotism rather than a philosophy of emotional restraint or moral responsibility. Do we want to live in such a society?

And since we return to the ancients to find wisdom for the modern age, to me the model human being is Socrates. He had an unwavering commitment to reason, emotional steadiness, and a stubborn refusal to act unjustly. In the face of death he reacted with calm and equanimity. Although not a Stoic (he lived earlier), he is the closest real-world example of a Stoic sage.


Thanks for reading The Modern Condition! This post is public so feel free to share it.

Share



📬

Newsletter

Stay updated with new articles.

0 Comments

Sign in to join the conversation.

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

© 2026 Modern Times , Powered by Writizzy