
Mary Wollstonecraft and the New Species of Power
Somewhere in Christiania, in a room at a cheap Danish inn in the late autumn of 1795, Mary Wollstonecraft sat down to write a letter and, almost casually, at the end, exposed the limits of two centuries of economic cheerfulness. She was travelling through Sweden, Norway, and Denmark, chasing a runaway silver shipment on behalf of a lover who did not deserve the trouble, and in between seasickness and heartbreak she found the time and the clarity to consider what might happen when commerce succeeded in destroying one form of power and created another.
âEngland and America owe their liberty to commerce, which created new species of power to undermine the feudal system. But let them beware of the consequence; the tyranny of wealth is still more galling and debasing than that of rank.â
Itâs just a short paragraph, but it still manages to say a lot. Wollstonecraft was not denying that commerce had helped free Europe from its feudal lords. What worried her was what came afterwards. Feudalism ran on bloodlines and the new order would run on capital. And capital, she feared, might turn out to be the more efficient and degrading tyrant, since it did not need a crown to justify itself. It only needs a market and enough wealth to determine the choices available to everyone else.
When I first read the passage, it was like something hit me. It didnât feel like reading a historical account written by a remarkable woman two centuries ago. It felt more like a diagnosis of the present.
Power speaks very differently now than it did in Wollstonecraftâs time, but the basic problem has not disappeared. What she wrote resonated with whatâs happening in the United States, where concentrated wealth can shape elections, legislation, regulation, and the ordinary conditions under which people live, while the institutions involved continue to describe themselves in the language of individual freedom and democratic choice. The duke expected deference because he was a duke. The donor expects access because he is a donor. The manners are different, but the assumption of privilege is not.
Scholars like Lena Halldenius have argued that Wollstonecraftâs work can be understood through the idea of âfreedom as non-domination,â that youâre not free just because no law is stopping you from doing something, but only if no one holds the power to interfere with your life at will. Economic inequality therefore can become a system of oppression that forces the non-wealthy into structural âmarket dependency,â a condition in which people without wealth must shape their choices, their labour, even their opinions, around the preferences of those who have it.
You can give someone the vote and still leave them economically powerless. You can tell them they are free to choose their employer, their home, or their future while arranging society so that the cost of making the wrong choice is unbearable. Political equality can look fine on paper while economic inequality quietly determines who has the practical ability to use it.
Wollstonecraft saw that while commerce broke the feudal power of hereditary rank, it created a ânew species of powerâ based on wealth and ownership. Modern corporatism has refined the formula, creating its own hierarchy. The names have changed. The mechanism of exclusion did not.
I donât believe that Wollstonecraft was prophetic in the usual sense. She was not predicting modern corporations, lobbying firms, campaign finance, or corporate personhood. What she was doing, I think, was asking what happens when a society removes one source of domination, but never stops to examine the new powers that replace it.
The problem was never simply that aristocrats had too much power. The problem was that people with too much power could make other people dependent on them.
Real freedom is not simply the absence of a law telling you what you cannot do. It requires us to address the structural rules of property and market relations that turn more and more aspects of human life into commodities, and decides who gets to be independent and who must remain dependent.
So perhaps the question we should ask is: What does freedom mean if the price of exercising it is determined by someone else?
Thank you for reading this Old Trouble. If you liked this piece or found it useful, share it, or consider subscribing. Or buy me a virtual coffee as caffeine keeps this whole enterprise running.
- Sources:
- Letters Written During a Short Residence in Sweden, Norway, and Denmark - Letter XIV
- Mary Wollstonecraft, our contemporary by By Catherine Packham| OUPblog
- Furniss T. Mary Wollstonecraftâs French Revolution. In: Johnson CL, ed. The Cambridge Companion to Mary Wollstonecraft . Cambridge Companions to Literature. Cambridge University Press; 2002:59-81.
- Halldenius, Lena, âThe Destructive Effects of Inequality: Mary Wollstonecraft and Strong Republican Egalitarianismâ, in Sandrine Bergès, and Alan Coffee (eds), Women and Republicanism (New York, NY, 2026; online edn, Oxford Academic, 6 Jan. 2026), https://doi.org/10.1093/9780197753262.003.0002
âď¸ Written by
Newsletter
Stay updated with new articles.

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!