Winning the War, Losing the Region
📅•⏱️3 min read

Winning the War, Losing the Region

If you only have time to read one article about the war in Iran, amid the current barrage of information and analysis, I’d recommend this week’s editorial in The Economist, titled “Donald Trump Must Stop Soon ,” and subtitled “His reckless conflict risks ending in chaos.” It is not freely accessible, but many public libraries, including mine, carry a subscription. It is worth the effort.

The Economist remains one of the few political magazines that still writes with the calm directness increasingly rare in today’s media. This week’s editorial remind readers of an uncomfortable truth. Hatred for a regime does not automatically produce a wise policy toward it. Those who believe the sheer odiousness of the Tehran regime is sufficient justification for what is now unfolding are embracing a position with an unfortunate track record.

I’d like remind everyone how many people cheered the abduction of Maduro, equally detestable, equally symbolic, and equally irrelevant to the actual suffering of Venezuelans. And if we look a bit further back, it’s worth recalling the disastrous consequences that followed the elimination of Gaddafi. Libya remains a failed state, still trapped in civil war. The pattern is consistent: removing the dictator does not remove the conditions that produced him.

Some people naively assume that anyone who opposes hasty and ill-planned interventions, is somehow siding with the mullahs. The bitter reality is that there is something even worse than dictatorial regimes: the unpredictable and completely uncontrollable chaos afterwards. And that leads to the only serious question that matters in moments like this. What happens next.

Subscribe now


The Economist’s answer is sobering. The United States and Israel have killed Iran’s supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, in a strike that has reshaped the Middle East overnight. Tehran has responded by installing three officials in charge as an interim leadership arrangement, a sign that, however militarily dominant the operation may be, its political goals remain uncertain.

On the battlefield, the coalition holds every advantage. Iran’s navy and air force have been destroyed and its missile infrastructure dismantled. US and Israeli forces can strike at will. And yet Tehran survives, expands the conflict sideways into Lebanon and the Gulf, and turns simple survival into a political victory.

Iran itself is also a fragile mosaic. Roughly 40% of the population belongs to ethnic minorities and Kurdish insurgents which already receive outside encouragement, could shatter the country entirely, destabilising Iraq, Syria, Turkey, and the Gulf states with it.

Israel’s war aim is clear: eliminate the threat posed by Iran’s regime. America’s, by contrast, is not. Washington has offered a menu of explanations, including Iran’s missiles, its nuclear programme, regime change, or simply a “feeling” that Iran was about to attack and settling scores after decades of enmity. This incoherence is the operation’s most dangerous flaw.

The economic consequences are already visible. Iran’s attempt to close the Strait of Hormuz has sent oil and gas prices surging. A prolonged war puts global growth and inflation at serious risk.

The rational course, the editorial argues, is to degrade Iran’s military capacity and stop - accepting an imperfect outcome instead of gambling on total victory. A wounded regime is survivable. A region in chaos, and a global recession, are not.

The greatest risk now is not Iran’s resilience. Trump’s impulsiveness is the real danger.
Thanks for reading Chronicles of a Liquid Society! This post is public so feel free to share it.

Share


📬

Newsletter

Stay updated with new articles.

0 Comments

Sign in to join the conversation.

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

© 2026 Modern Times , Powered by Writizzy